'Not Fit for This Chair': Lawyer Targets CJI Surya Kant in Supreme Court

'Not Fit for This Chair': Lawyer Targets CJI Surya Kant in Supreme Court

Dramatic scenes unfolded inside Courtroom No. 1 of the Supreme Court of India in New Delhi on Monday, November 16, 2026, after an agitated lawyer disrupted afternoon proceedings to challenge the integrity and eligibility of Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant over the non-listing of a matter submitted on November 2. According to lawyers present in the courtroom and multiple legal reports, the incident occurred around 2:00 PM when a three-judge bench comprising CJI Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice V. Mohana assembled for the post-lunch session while adjudicating motor accident compensation claims. Approaching the podium without following established rules for urgent mentioning, the counsel insisted that his papers—which reportedly related to a contempt matter—had been submitted to the Chief Justice's office on November 2, yet remained unlisted after fifteen days. When the bench objected to the unscheduled interruption, directed him to approach the Registrar under standard mentioning protocol, and CJI Surya Kant calmly assured him that the court would examine the papers if he waited, the lawyer lost his temper and declared aloud: "No, I will not wait. You cannot sit in that chair. You do not deserve it. You do not have the integrity for that". Court officials immediately switched off the live audio-video transmission feed of the courtroom, and security personnel escorted the counsel outside. Following the outburst, senior members of the Supreme Court Bar expressed strong disapproval of the breach of judicial decorum and met the Chief Justice to urge formal contempt of court proceedings against the advocate. Meanwhile, a Supreme Court Registry official clarified that case listing is governed by automated court software rather than personal intervention by the CJI, noting that a large volume of filings accumulated prior to November 6 ahead of the week-long Diwali court recess. For legal professionals, litigants, and citizens across New Delhi, Lucknow, Prayagraj, Kanpur, Varanasi, Patna, Mumbai, Bengaluru, Chennai, and Kolkata, the episode has reignited urgent conversations around courtroom discipline, Bar-Bench mutual respect, and digital listing transparency in India's apex court.

What Triggered the Outburst in Supreme Court Courtroom No. 1

According to eyewitness accounts from advocates inside Courtroom No. 1, the confrontation began immediately after the bench resumed work at 2:00 PM on Monday. While the three-judge bench was hearing scheduled motor accident claim appeals, the lawyer stepped forward without prior listing permission and stated that he had submitted an application to the CJI's office on November 2 without receiving any reply over the ensuing two weeks.

Aspect of the Incident Verified Courtroom & Registry Details
Date, Time & Courtroom Monday, November 16, 2026, around 2:00 PM, in Courtroom No. 1, Supreme Court of India (New Delhi)
Presiding Bench Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice V. Mohana
Lawyer's Grievance Claimed an application/petition submitted on November 2 had not been listed even after 15 days despite intimation
Bench's Response & Outburst Bench objected to unscheduled mentioning and asked him to wait; counsel flared up, saying CJI lacked integrity and did not deserve the chair
Immediate Action Taken Courtroom audio-video feed switched off, security escorted the lawyer out, and Bar members sought contempt proceedings

Justice V. Mohana pointed out that matters could not be mentioned orally in such an irregular manner. The counsel replied that he wished to tender an apology first because his situation was an emergency and urged the judges to inspect his papers immediately. When CJI Surya Kant responded patiently—"We will see, you just wait"—the lawyer refused to step back, expressing respect for Justices Bagchi and Mohana while launching a direct personal attack on the Chief Justice's integrity and fitness to hold office.

Why the Petition Was Delayed: Supreme Court Registry Explains Automated Listing

Addressing questions surrounding the non-listing of the November 2 filing, a Supreme Court Registry official explained that the scheduling and allocation of petitions are processed through an automated court listing software system, in which the Chief Justice has no direct role. The official further noted that a substantial backlog of petitions was filed just before November 6, immediately after which the Supreme Court remained closed for a full week on account of the Diwali holidays, naturally extending standard scrutiny and listing timelines.

Bar Members Condemn Breach of Decorum and Demand Contempt Action

Inside the courtroom, the abrupt muting of the live audio-video feed was followed swiftly by security personnel escorting the counsel out of the hall. Several advocates witnessing the exchange expressed deep concern over the unprovoked personal remarks aimed at the head of the Indian judiciary. Later, members of the Bar called upon Chief Justice Surya Kant and formally requested that contempt of court proceedings be initiated against the lawyer—who, according to courtroom observers, is not a regular member of the Supreme Court Bar—to uphold institutional dignity. Legal observers also noted that the incident follows earlier courtroom disruptions this year, including a July episode involving a distressed petitioner-in-person that prompted tighter controls over courtroom audio-video transmissions. As of Tuesday morning, no formal written order regarding contempt action had been uploaded on the Supreme Court website.