Why Didn't Ramayana Songs Become Hits, Javed Akhtar Gives Witty Reply
Even as director Nitesh Tiwari's mythological spectacle Ramayana: Part 1 continues its historic march toward the ₹1,500-crore worldwide box-office milestone, one aspect of the Namit Malhotra production has sparked lively debate among listeners and critics alike: its soundtrack. Composed by A.R. Rahman and Hans Zimmer with lyrics penned by Kumar Vishwas, the film's songs have drawn a decidedly mixed reception compared to its universally lauded visual scale—prompting comparisons with timeless Ramayana-themed compositions from earlier Hindi films, most notably "Pal Pal Hai Bhaari" from Ashutosh Gowariker's 2004 classic Swades, written by veteran lyricist Javed Akhtar. Speaking to reporters on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, at the launch of the Indian Performing Right Society's (IPRS) "Music Creator Report" in Mumbai, the 81-year-old screenwriter and poet offered a characteristically witty response when asked why Ramayana's songs have struggled to strike the same emotional chord as his Swades verses. With a playful smile, Javed Akhtar remarked: "I am a good writer, so the lines I write touch people." While candidly admitting that he has not yet watched Ramayana himself, Akhtar revealed that his daughter, acclaimed filmmaker Zoya Akhtar, has already seen the Ranbir Kapoor, Sai Pallavi, and Yash starrer and walked away thoroughly impressed. "I haven't watched the film yet. My daughter (Zoya) has seen it, and she has been praising it; she praises things with great difficulty. I haven't heard her praising me yet," Akhtar told news agency PTI. Beyond cinema and music, the veteran writer also reflected deeply on the cultural and moral stature of Lord Ram, describing him not merely as a historical or religious figure, but as "an ideal, a morality, and a way of living" whose essence runs in the blood of every Indian irrespective of faith. For cinema enthusiasts, music lovers, and cultural readers across Mumbai, New Delhi, Lucknow, Ayodhya, Varanasi, Prayagraj, Bengaluru, Hyderabad, Chennai, and Kolkata, Javed Akhtar's candid remarks highlight both the enduring power of soulful lyricism and the rare praise Ramayana has earned from one of Bollywood's most discerning directors.
Inside Javed Akhtar's Remarks on 'Ramayana' Music, Zoya Akhtar's Review, and Lord Ram
Delivered during the IPRS Music Creator Report launch event, Javed Akhtar's observations spanned three distinct themes—from playful pride in his songwriting craft to philosophical reflections on Indian heritage:
| Discussion Theme | Javed Akhtar's Verified Statement & Context (Nov 17–18, 2026) | Cultural & Industry Significance |
| On Why Ramayana Songs Missed the Mark vs. Swades | Quipped with signature wit: "I am a good writer, so the lines I write touch people," contrasting his Swades classic "Pal Pal Hai Bhaari" ("Mann se Ravan jo nikale, Ram uske mann mein hai") with Ramayana's soundtrack. | Highlights how deeply philosophical, emotionally accessible lyrics endure across decades compared to grandiose background-driven scores. |
| Zoya Akhtar's Rare Praise for Ramayana | Told PTI: "I haven't watched the film yet. My daughter (Zoya) has seen it, and she has been praising it; she praises things with great difficulty. I haven't heard her praising me yet." | Coming from notoriously selective filmmaker Zoya Akhtar, her endorsement underscores Ramayana's cinematic craft and visual scale. |
| On Lord Ram as a Universal Moral Ideal | Recited a couplet by poet Rahim and stated: "Ram is not just a person, Ram is an ideal, a morality, Ram is a way of living... the essence of Ram runs in the blood of every Indian, irrespective of religion." | Frames Lord Ram as an ethical and aesthetic cornerstone shared across India's pluralistic cultural fabric. |
| About Nitesh Tiwari's Ramayana Ensemble & Sequel | Directed by Nitesh Tiwari, produced by Namit Malhotra; stars Ranbir Kapoor (Rama), Sai Pallavi (Sita), Yash (Ravana), Ravie Dubey (Lakshman), Sunny Deol (Hanuman), and Arun Govil (Dasharatha). | Released on Nov 5, 2026; Ramayana: Part 2 is scheduled for worldwide theatrical release on Diwali 2028. |
Why 'Pal Pal Hai Bhaari' Remains the Gold Standard for Ramayana-Inspired Lyrics
During the interaction, the conversation naturally turned to "Pal Pal Hai Bhaari"—the beloved track Javed Akhtar penned for A.R. Rahman in Ashutosh Gowariker's 2004 drama Swades. Lines such as "Mann se Ravan jo nikale, Ram uske mann mein hai" ("Whoever banishes Ravana from their mind holds Ram within their heart") transformed a theatrical Ramleela sequence into an unforgettable moral reflection.
Even though A.R. Rahman also co-composed the score for Nitesh Tiwari's Ramayana alongside Hans Zimmer (with lyrics by Kumar Vishwas), listeners have largely viewed the new soundtrack as an atmospheric orchestral accompaniment rather than a collection of standalone chartbusters. Javed Akhtar's tongue-in-cheek remark—followed by his recitation of a classic couplet by poet Rahim—captured why unforgettable words remain the soul of Indian film music.
Zoya Akhtar's Endorsement and the Road Ahead for 'Ramayana: Part 2'
While Javed Akhtar plans to catch Ramayana: Part 1 soon, knowing that his famously hard-to-please daughter Zoya Akhtar praised Nitesh Tiwari's execution adds further prestige to a film already dominating global box offices. Featuring Ranbir Kapoor, Sai Pallavi, Yash, Ravie Dubey, Sunny Deol, and Arun Govil, the two-part saga will return to theaters with Ramayana: Part 2 on Diwali 2028.